You're Allowed to Question a Witness About the Fact that He's a Liar

 

In the case of the United States versus Jorge Cedeno, the trial judge prevented Cedeno’s lawyer from questioning a detective about the fact that he had lied (and been caught lying) in a prior court proceeding in an unrelated case. 

 

The trial judge prevented such questioning after considering:

 

1.    Whether the prior judicial finding addressed the detective’s honesty in that specific case or generally; and

 

2.    Whether the two sets of testimony involved a similar subject.

 

The court of appeals disagreed with the trial judge, however, concluding that he should have also considered such things as:

 

  • Whether the lie was under oath in a judicial proceeding or was made in a less formal setting;

 

  • Whether the lie was about a matter that was important or trivial; 

 

  • How much time had gone by since the lie was told;

 

  • Whether there had been any intervening credibility determination regarding the witness;

 

  • The apparent motive for the lie and whether a similar motive existed in the current proceeding; and

 

  • Whether the witness offered an explanation for the lie and, if so, whether his explanation was plausible.

Share This Blog

HACER UNA PREGUNTA,
DESCRIBE TU SITUACIÓN,
SOLICITA UNA CONSULTA

Llama ahora: (561) 832-4348

Contact Form Sidebar
* Campos RequeridosCampos Requeridos
Su Información Está Segura con Nosotros

Respetamos su privacidad. La información que nos brinda será utilizada para responder sus preguntas o agendar una cita si usted así lo solicita.

Follow Us On

400 Clematis St. Suite 206, West Palm Beach, FL 33401
SI TIENE PREGUNTAS O DESEA AGENDAR UNA CITA PRESIONE AQUÍ PARA LLAMAR AL (561) 832-4348
Desde 1990, el Sr. Chapman ha representado a personas que han sido acusadas de cometer delitos de varios tipos, tales como DUI, violencia doméstica, posesión de armas, posesión de drogas, eliminación de antecedentes penales, infracciones de tránsito, asesinato, homicidio involuntario, abuso infantil, delitos sexuales, abuso de personas mayores, apelaciones y violaciones de libertad condicional.
Abogado de Defensa Criminal en West Palm Beach, FL

© Propiedad Intelectual 2024. Abogado Penalista en Florida. Todos los Derechos Reservados.

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram